Batman: Death in the Family (BD/S)
M**T
Outstanding moral dilemma film
The film makers have presented a dramatic illustration of the consequences of moral decisions in the case of the death of Jason Todd as the second Robin. This "interactive film" is also some of the best DC animation to date. As the story unfolds, at the first key point in the action you are presented with the choice of whether Robin lives or dies. Then you choose. The dramatic consequences follow. He dies. Or he cheats death and recovers. Or Batman saves Robin and he lives, but Batman dies, and more choices follow. The film promises seven possible endings. Actually there are eight. The whole film with viewing all the alternate choices takes about three hours, if you go back to the beginning each time. Some terms used in the dialogue may be unfamiliar, so activating the subtitling feature at the beginning can be useful (for example, "parcour"). If you read the rest of this review be aware that there are a few spoilers. Also included are four additional DC Showcase Shorts: Sgt. Rock; Adam Strange; The Phantom Stranger; and Death.Batman: Death in the Family. PLAY does not begin the movie, but gives instructions. You are given the choice to skip instructions. When you choose BEGIN STORY, the story doesn't begin. The standard "intro" to each of the DC Showcase Shorts starts, with the comic books store, and the rotating comics rack in the back with the title comic book rotated into view close up. Then the action begins with the titling sequence as the beginning of the story line. Each time you select to go back to the MAIN TITLE to view a different alternate story line from the beginning of the action, the same instructions or skip Instructions and the BEGIN STORY with the "Showcase intro" occurs all over again before the action of the titling sequence begins. If you don't want that, then at the end credits choose the INTRODUCTION from the "scenes" menu offered, which skips the beginning action in the main titling sequence and plays to the first choice, ROBIN DIES, BUT YOU CAN SAVE HIM. I will outline here what I found to be the best sequence of viewing all the alternate story lines.MAIN TITLE SEQUENCE Action. A heavy industrial case with radioactive emblem is handed by the laughing Joker to Ra's al Ghul in Serajevo, Bosnia, and next is being transferred in a van guarded by terrorists. Batman pursues on the Batcycle, dodging RPGs and bullets, disables several of the terrorists with batarangs, and demolishes one of the vans with an explosive device, and retrieves from the broken-open case the radio-active device.INTRODUCTION. Batman speeds toward the town, where, in a warehouse, the Joker is beating Robin/Jason with a crowbar. Intermittant flashbacks as Batman speeds on the Batcycle reveal that Robin while apprehending criminals with Batman, broke the collarbone of one of them, sending him into shock, ruining a chance to get him to talk. Bruce tells Alfred that Jason is not ready, that he himself had the help of Alfred as he grew up, but Jason, whose parents died tragically, is still in pain and not ready for action in the field, that he is a danger to himself and to their mission, and Bruce was going to take him off active duty immediately. Jason heard this and left in anger. Later, Jason is found by Bruce in Bosnia. Jason was going after the Joker, and Bruce was after Ra's al Ghul, not Jason. They share info that Joker had acquired stolen uranium to sell to terrorists, and that Ra's is planning on building "dirty bombs" to poison thousands, millions of people. They have tracked the uranium shipments to Joker and Ra's in Serajevo. The terrorists are in vans on the way to cross the border and need to be stopped. Robin points out that the Batcycle only seats one, and he himself will check out the warehouse while Batman pursues the terrorists. Batman forbids Robin to confront the Joker, because he is too dangerous to confront alone. Robin disagrees, but Batman orders him to wait until he returns. Robin sullenly says he will wait. This references the chase scene at the beginning of the film. Interestingly, the film does not offer the option that Robin waits, so that choice is not available. Batman speeds off in pursuit of the terrorists. But Joker is now beating Robin, who obviously ignored Batman's warning. He leaves Robin seriously wounded, saying as he prepared to depart, "When you see him, tell him I said 'Hello'." He leaves and Robin painfully drags himself to the door, but finds it padlocked, and a timer wired to explosives ticks off nine seconds. The film pauses at this point. Three choices are offered. Robin dies, but you can save him. Choose one. Robin cheats death. Robin dies. Batman saves Robin.1. ROBIN DIES. The warehouse explodes. Batman is too late. Jason is buried in a cemetery. Later, in a diner, Bruce relates what followed. Ra's al Ghul secretly recovered Jason's body out of regret over his death, and resurrected him with the Lazarus Pit, but it made Jason insane. Jason later recovers and becomes Red Hood. Bruce Wayne relates an abbreviation of the highlights of the events in the film, Batman: Under the Red Hood. Bruce finishes the story. He is talking to Clark Kent/Superman. They agree the Red Hood must be found and stopped. END CREDITS follow, with a "scenes" menu displayed at bottom of screen. MAIN TITLE, INTRODUCTION, ROBIN DIES. click on one. Choose ROBIN CHEATS DEATH.2. ROBIN CHEATS DEATH. The warehouse explodes. Batman finds Robin in the rubble. During a long and painful convalescence and recovery, Jason refuses to believe the support given him by the Wayne/Batman family and the Justice League is sincere, but only hypocritical lies. He secretly plans to kill the Joker, and to find him he becomes Red Robin. He takes over the criminal element of Gotham with violence. Joker traps Red Robin's gang leaders in a semi-trailer, soaks them with gasoline, and burns them to death, surrounded by the police and commissioner Gordon. Red Robin taunts Joker with fact that challenging him was the only way to bring him out of hiding. He kills the Joker and escapes the police. On the top of the Wayne Industries Building, Red Robin is confronted by Talia al Ghul, who seeks to recruit him to the League of Assassins. Jason refuses, until Talia reveals that she is holding an infant, Damian, the son of Batman/Bruce Wayne. She proposes that Jason raise her and Bruce's son and train Damian to lead the League of Assassins. Jason now agrees, silently vowing to use Damian to bring down both the House of Wayne and the House of Al Ghul "from the inside" and take over. END CREDITS follow, with "scenes" menu. MAIN TITLE, INTRODUCTION, ROBIN DIES. Click on one. Choose BATMAN SAVES ROBIN.3. BATMAN SAVES ROBIN. Batman speedily arrives at the warehouse with eleven seconds remaining (instead of nine) ticking off on the explosive. He quickly opens the door (apparently not padlocked) picks up Robin and gets to the door at the moment the warehouse explodes. Robin regains consciousness, and finds Batman mortally wounded. Before his dies, Bruce begs Jason to promise he will not kill the Joker, but work for justice for the sake of Alfred, Dick, and Barbara, and the Joker, because killing will not make the internal pain stop, and is the only way to heal. He dies before Jason says yes or no. BATMAN DIES: CATCH THE JOKER or KILL THE JOKER. Choose KILL THE JOKER.KILL THE JOKER. Funeral for Bruce Wayne. Jason returns to the Batcave, and silently resolves to kill the Joker. He resents stories of Batman's nobility, and the emotional support offered by the rest of the family and by members of the Justice League, but he lies about his own personal recovery going well. He later happens to go into a diner, where the newscast is talking about Batman, and gets into a conversation with a man who says he used to know Batman. This man says he's in recovery, and keeps a journal, in which he tells himself and his therapist that he's a different man, now. He tells Jason a joke, which Jason recognizes is a documented part of the case record Jason had seen in the files in the Batcave computer (as seen at the end of Batman: The Killing Joke), and he realizes that this man is the Joker. Jason remembers the video files of Joker's crimes of violence and his own beating, and he says to him that he decided to "say 'Hello'." The man smiles with the sudden realization that he's talking to "The Boy Wonder". Jason immediately stabs him in the right eye with a table knife. Joker dies, laughing, and two police officers arriving on the scene order Jason to surrender, he's under arrest. JOKER DIES: ATTACK or SURRENDER. Choose SURRENDER.SURRENDER. Jason is convicted and sentenced to life. In prison, Jason believes he was totally justified in killing the Joker. Murder. Execution. Justice. His hands are now tattooed with a Batman symbol on the back of his right hand, a Robin symbol on the back of his left, and on the back of each of the four fingers of his hands are individual letters spelling out "JAIL BIRD". He is resolved to continue executing "justice on the inside". He smiles. END CREDITS follow, with "scenes" menu. MAIN TITLE, INTRODUCTION, ROBIN DIES, BATMAN SAVES ROBIN, ROBIN AT CROSSROADS, KILL THE JOKER. Choose KILL THE JOKER.4. ROBIN AT CROSSROADS: KILL THE JOKER. The same story as above in 3: BATMAN SAVES ROBIN. Jason kills the Joker, and two police officers arrive. JOKER DIES: ATTACK or SURRENDER. Choose ATTACK.ATTACK. Jason attacks the nearest officer and holds off the second. He leaves and eludes capture. Jason becomes Red Robin, terrorizing the criminal community and Gotham. He confronts Two-Face in a Mall, who defeats him in an attack, with Red Robin/Jason knocked down by a falling display stand, without his weapon at hand, his gun tossed aside. Two-Face presents the dilemma of life or death. He flips his coin. IMAGE OF THE COIN: SCARRED SIDE OR UNSCARRED SIDE. Choose the image of the SCARRED SIDE.SCARRED SIDE. Two-Face, seeing this, says "death", and confronts Red Robin with the violence of Red Robin's crimes of murder in the criminal community, that he is far worse, and decides to let him live with the paralyzing guilty knowledge of what he has done, a dead soul, and he leaves. "Live with it". END CREDITS follow, with "scenes" menu. ROBIN AT CROSSROADS: JOKER DIES: ATTACK: TWO-FACE'S COIN: SCARRED SIDE or UNSCARRED SIDE.5. UNSCARRED SIDE. The story is the same as above 4. Two-Face takes the unscarred side as his decision to do good, and kill Red Robin for his crimes in terrorizing Gotham. The moment he is about to fire, he is fired-on, by a young boy holding Red Robin's gun. Red Robin takes back his gun, but he is urged by the boy to not kill Two-Face, and reminds him of the ideals of Batman and Nightwing, telling him that killing is not the way. Jason relents and agrees, and he tosses away the gun. letting Two-Face go. The boy is Tim Drake. Red Robin decides he will train him. Meanwhile, Jason seeks reconciliation with Dick Grayson, Alfred, Barbara, and her father commissioner Gordon. He becomes a crime-fighter like the original Batman, as Red Robin reformed, together with his partner Tim Drake in training as Batkid. END CREDITS follow, with "scenes" menu. MAIN TITLE: INTRODUCTION: BATMAN SAVES ROBIN: ROBIN AT CROSSROADS. Choose CATCH THE JOKER.6. CATCH THE JOKER. Story is the same as above 3: Batman saves Robin, up to the point of choosing to Kill the Joker or Catch the Joker. He resolves to catch him. But he has to find him. Jason becomes the Red Hood. This time when Joker has Red Hood's gang leaders soaked in gasoline in the semitrailer, surrounded by police, his lighter won't light, and Red Hood taunts him with fact that challenging him was the only way to bring him out of hiding. Jason comes down, sets off a smoke bomb, and in the cloud of smoke handcuffs and confronts the Joker, who confronts Red Robin with being a pathological killer. Jason. holding a gun on Joker, denies that he has killed anyone, keeping his promise to Batman. But Joker cites every instance of Red Robin murdering every one of those Red Robin had apprehended, and suddenly he discovers to his delight that Red Robin has repressed his memory of killing, making Red Robin Joker's son, not Batman's, and he laughs at Jason/Red Robin as he presses his forehead against Jason's gun, trying to provoke him to kill. JOKER DIES: KILL THE JOKER or SPARE THE JOKER. Choose KILL THE JOKER.KILL THE JOKER. Jason kills Joker, concealed by the smoke, and escapes to the top of the Wayne Industries Building, while commissioner Gordon and his officers discover Joker's corpse. Talia al Ghul confronts Jason there, congratulates him and urges him as an excellent assassin to join the League of Assassins. Jason refuses. She tells him he will have to persuade Batman. Ra's refused to resurrect Bruce, but Talia did, and Bruce regained his abilities as Batman under her care, except for his speech. He only says menacingly, "Zur-En-Arrh". He draws forth a dagger in challenge to Jason. The choice is FIGHT TO THE DEATH: DEATH or LIFE. Choose DEATH.DEATH. They collide in attack. Batman pierces Red Robin's left forearm with the dagger, as Jason simultaneously stabs Bruce in the heart. Batman collapses. Talia shoots Jason in his Red Hood helmet. Jason tosses the helmet aside and goes over to Batman and turns him over. Batman has an activated IED in his left hand. It explodes, demolishing the top of the Wayne Industries Building. Talia, Bruce, and Jason all are killed. Only charred corpses remain. END CREDITS follow, with "scenes" menu. MAIN TITLE: INTRODUCTION: ROBIN DIES: BATMAN SAVES ROBIN: CATCH THE JOKER: KILL THE JOKER: FIGHT TO THE DEATH: DEATH or LIFE. Choose LIFE.7. LIFE. Jason avoids stabbing Bruce. As he falls back Jason immediately tazes Batman, who falls unconscious. Talia shoots Jason in his Red Hood helmet. Jason tosses it past her, as she prepares to kill him, and Jason presses a switch in his hand that causes the Red Hood helmet to explode, knocking Talia unconscious. All three of them live. Jason becomes reconciled to the Wayne/Batman family, including Barbara and her father commissioner Gordon, and becomes reformed, coordinating his efforts with Dick and the police from the Batcave, but not going back yet to active duty, because of issues of nightmares and PTSD. Nightwing has become the new Batman. Bruce is still alive, and is dangerous, but he is restrained and under care in Arkham Asylum. As he mutters, "Zor-in-Arrh", he remembers his father's last words, that if Zorro came riding into Gotham on his horse, it would end with "Zorro in Arkham". END CREDITS follow, with "scenes" menu. MAIN TITLE: INTRODUCTION: ROBIN DIES: BATMAN SAVES ROBIN: ROBIN AT CROSSROADS: CATCH THE JOKER: KILL THE JOKER: KILL THE JOKER or SPARE THE JOKER. Choose SPARE THE JOKER.8. SPARE THE JOKER. Story is the same as above 7, except instead of killing the Joker, Jason/Red Hood knocks him unconscious, and eludes capture. The police close in on a handcuffed Joker, who is still alive. Jason, Talia, and Bruce confront each other on the top of the Wayne Industries Building, and the fight to the death ends with life. Bruce is tazed and knocked out. Talia shoots Red Hood in the helmet. Jason tosses it past her and explodes it. Jason is reconciled and accepted, and Bruce is in Arkham Asylum. END CREDITS follow, with "scenes" menu.I suggest you not try to watch the whole thing all at once. That might be a bit obsessive. I enjoyed it.
A**L
Recomendadísimo
Buenísimo. Supero mis expectativas, que ya eran altas. Muy recomendado.
M**R
BECOME THE STORY
While the Marvel Universe has taken over the feature film world with their numerous hits the same can’t be said for those movies based on DC characters. I’ve always felt in part that was due to the fact the folks at Warner Brothers have shied away from the source material as if to say comic books are unworthy of their efforts. Marvel instead embraces those roots. Fortunately those in charge of Warner’s animated division they don’t follow that path.The animated DC Universe is alive and well with movies flowing along at a fast pace and more often than not sticking to that great source material their chosen stories are derived from. Just released is one story that they’ve taken an extra step with. BATMAN: DEATH IN THE FAMILY is that release and the new addition they’ve added is making it an interactive story. You the viewer get to decide how the story plays out.The set up first. For those who’ve not kept up on the comics DEATH IN THE FAMILY was a huge storyline in the Batman comics. Dick Grayson aka Robin had grown up and moved on becoming Nightwing. A chance encounter led Batman to pick up a new replacement for Robin in Jason Todd, a young orphan Batman rescued and took on much like he had Grayson. While the setup was the same the two young men were different in their approach. In 1988 writer Dennis O’Neill suggested they allow readers to determine the fate of Todd and thus the story DEATH IN THE FAMILY came about. Readers were allowed to vote and determine if Todd lived or died.The interactive movie takes on that same approach. Batman finds himself in Bosnia tracking down arch-enemy Ras al-Ghul who is set to purchase uranium to create dirty bombs. He finds the disillusioned Jason Todd there tracking down the Joker who it turns out is the seller of that uranium. As Batman follows al-Ghul’s men and the uranium, Todd enters a warehouse to confront the Joker. But the Joker is prepared and captures Todd. In one of the most brutal moments in both comic book and animated history Todd/Robin is beaten with a crowbar and left to die. As he attempts to escape he see a bomb counting down the seconds, death imminent.Here is where the first path must be chosen by the viewer. Three options are presented. 1, have Batman rescue Todd. 2, have Batman fail and Todd die. And 3, have Todd save himself. Each choice leads the path down to various other choices, some lengthier than others. Each choice has consequences. I won’t reveal those outcomes but it’s safe to say they are not always the ones you would expect.But it doesn’t end there. SPOILER ALERT FOR NON-COMIC FANS. Those who have kept up with the comics know that Jason Todd did die in that vote back in 1988 but was resurrected and later became the Red Hood. Most of the stories that progress from this point use that character. But each choice leads to more choices and more stories. Does Todd kill the Joker or let him live? Does Todd become a force for good or for evil? Does Batman survive or die? Does Ras al-Ghul step in to save either of these characters?The potential of storylines is so large that the odds of covering them all in one sitting aren’t likely. I know after 90 minutes I had to stop to view the other items included here as to write this review. I will be returning to explore them all though. It’s an ingenious gimmick that works well. Combined with the fact that the production values on the DC animated side of things are always top notch and you have a real treat to enjoy here.If that wasn’t enough they are also including 4 shorts from the DC Showcase as well. Showcase was the DC comic that featured a rotating series of guests’ stars in the lead story and the same holds true here. One involved the WWII hero Sgt. Rock, another the sci-fi adventures of Adam Strange, a third the mysterious Phantom Stranger and the fourth from the world of the Sandman an episode involving Death. All are done with the same quality found in the main item here.The use of the various storylines, some using the same footage with different outcomes and endings, is fascinating to watch as they unspool. Just know this is not your old style comic book animated feature. The movie comes with an R rating due to the violence depicted. This is more along the lines of something for fans in the adult category. Consider me one and I heartily recommend this as something worth watching and enjoying more than once.
S**S
hello
i like batman! this movies was great to watch!
Trustpilot
1 day ago
2 weeks ago